Measure held-readback phase and refuse implementation targets before hashing

This commit is contained in:
Shirofune-Security committed 2026-09-21 22:51:50 +09:00
1 parent 03bc63e996
commit d832b1e090
10 files changed
+93 -29

No files matched your search

+9 -4
View File
@@ -10,7 +10,7 @@ function New-Fixture {
$script:reader=[pscustomobject]@{Computer='FIXTURE';ProcessId=1234;UserSid=$script:token.Sid;UserName=$script:token.Name;TokenId='1';AuthenticationId='4660';ModifiedId='2';GroupSids=@('S-1-1-0');GroupCount=1;PrivilegeCount=1;ElevatedAdministrator=$true;TokenType='Primary';Impersonation='Absent'}
$script:state=[pscustomobject]@{Computer='FIXTURE';Host=[pscustomobject]@{ProductType=3;Build=20348;DomainJoined=$false;Domain='WORKGROUP'};MachineGuid='01234567-89ab-cdef-0123-456789abcdef';Services=@([pscustomobject]@{Name='EventLog';Status='Running'},[pscustomobject]@{Name='RpcSs';Status='Running'},[pscustomobject]@{Name='Winmgmt';Status='Running'});Reader=($script:reader|Select-Object UserSid,UserName,AuthenticationId,GroupSids,GroupCount,PrivilegeCount,ElevatedAdministrator,TokenType,Impersonation);Token=(Copy-Value $script:token);File=[pscustomobject]@{Path='C:\Fixture\ReadCase.TxT';NativePath='\Device\HarddiskVolume5\Fixture\ReadCase.TxT';Identity='1:2:3:1339999';Size=32;LastWriteUtc='2026-09-20T00:00:00.0000000Z';DescriptorBase64='AA==';StateKey=('a'*64);Attributes=32;Links=1;SecurityInformation=511;Aces=@([pscustomobject]@{Type=2;Flags=64;Mask=1;Sid='S-1-1-0';Ordinary=$true;Binary='AA=='})};AuditPolicies=[pscustomobject]@{'0CCE921D-69AE-11D9-BED3-505054503030'=1};Precedence=[pscustomobject]@{KeyExists=$true;ValueExists=$true;Value=1;Type='DWord'};Channel=[pscustomobject]@{Name='Security';Enabled=$true;SecurityDescriptor='O:SYG:SYD:'};Engine='C:\Windows\System32\WindowsPowerShell\v1.0\powershell.exe';EngineHash=('b'*64);Sources=[pscustomobject]@{Source=('c'*64)}}
$script:nonce='d'*32
$script:operation=[pscustomobject]@{Kind='WelaOneByteFileRead';Nonce=$script:nonce;ProcessId=1234;Executable=$script:state.Engine;FilePath=$script:state.File.Path;BeforeReader=(Copy-Value $script:reader);AfterReader=(Copy-Value $script:reader);BeforeToken=(Copy-Value $script:token);AfterToken=(Copy-Value $script:token);Read=[pscustomobject]@{Clock='GetSystemTimePreciseAsFileTime';Succeeded=$true;ReadCalls=1;BytesRead=1;HandleId='0x888';BeforeKey=('a'*64);AfterKey=('a'*64);StartedUtc='2026-09-21T00:00:00.0001000Z';CompletedUtc='2026-09-21T00:00:00.0002000Z'};RecordIdBefore=10}
$script:operation=[pscustomobject]@{Kind='WelaOneByteFileRead';Nonce=$script:nonce;ProcessId=1234;Executable=$script:state.Engine;FilePath=$script:state.File.Path;BeforeReader=(Copy-Value $script:reader);AfterReader=(Copy-Value $script:reader);BeforeToken=(Copy-Value $script:token);AfterToken=(Copy-Value $script:token);Read=[pscustomobject]@{Clock='GetSystemTimePreciseAsFileTime';Phase='OneByteReadAndHeldIdentityReadback';Succeeded=$true;ReadCalls=1;BytesRead=1;HandleId='0x888';BeforeKey=('a'*64);AfterKey=('a'*64);StartedUtc='2026-09-21T00:00:00.0001000Z';ReadReturnedUtc='2026-09-21T00:00:00.0001600Z';CompletedUtc='2026-09-21T00:00:00.0002000Z'};RecordIdBefore=10}
$script:reads=0;$script:batchMode='match';$script:afterDrift=$false;$script:workerFailure=$false;$script:failArtifact=$null
}
function Native-Xml {
@@ -22,6 +22,10 @@ New-Fixture
$null=Get-WelaFileProbeStateKey $script:state;Assert $true 'complete native prerequisites are accepted'
Assert-WelaFileProbeOperation $script:operation $script:state $script:nonce 1234 ([datetimeoffset]'2026-09-21T00:00:00Z') ([datetimeoffset]'2026-09-21T00:00:01Z');Assert $true 'one precise same-token byte read is accepted'
foreach($path in @('','relative.txt','\\host\share\file','C:\a:stream','C:\a\..\file','C:\a\file.','C:\a\file ','C:\a\file*','C:\a\','C:\a\\file','C:/file',('C:\'+('a'*240)))){Reject {Assert-WelaFileProbePath $path} 'exact ordinary'}
$scopeSource=[pscustomobject]@{Path='C:\WELA\WELA.ps1'};$scopeEngine=[pscustomobject]@{Path='C:\Windows\System32\WindowsPowerShell\v1.0\powershell.exe'}
foreach($path in @('C:\Data\ordinary.txt','C:\WELA-other\ordinary.txt')){$selected=[pscustomobject]@{Path=$path;Links=1;Attributes=32};Assert-WelaFileProbeScopeObservation $path $selected $scopeSource $scopeEngine;Assert $true 'ordinary targets outside the canonical implementation tree are allowed'}
foreach($path in @('C:\WELA\WELA.ps1','c:\wela\scripts\FileAccessProbeNative.cs',$scopeEngine.Path)){$selected=[pscustomobject]@{Path=$path;Links=1;Attributes=32};Reject {Assert-WelaFileProbeScopeObservation $path $selected $scopeSource $scopeEngine} 'source tree|active PowerShell engine'}
foreach($mode in @('alias','links','reparse','typed-links')){$selected=[pscustomobject]@{Path='C:\Data\ordinary.txt';Links=1;Attributes=32};$inputPath=$selected.Path;switch($mode){'alias' {$inputPath='C:\Alias\ordinary.txt'};'links' {$selected.Links=2};'reparse' {$selected.Attributes=1024};'typed-links' {$selected.Links=$true}};Reject {Assert-WelaFileProbeScopeObservation $inputPath $selected $scopeSource $scopeEngine} 'ordinary canonical single-link'}
foreach($name in @('computer','machine','host-build','host-product','joined','service','token-source','token-sid','token-group','token-privilege','file-path','native-path','file-key','descriptor','size','links','sections','ace-ordinary','ace-type','ace-mask','ace-sid','channel-name','channel-enabled','precedence-type','precedence-value','mask','reader-type','reader-impersonation','engine','source')){
New-Fixture
switch($name){
@@ -39,9 +43,9 @@ foreach($name in @('deny-only','disabled-group','inherit-only','failure-ace','ca
switch($name){'deny-only' {$script:state.Token.Groups[0].Attributes=16};'disabled-group' {$script:state.Token.Groups[0].Attributes=0};'inherit-only' {$script:state.File.Aces[0].Flags=72};'failure-ace' {$script:state.File.Aces[0].Flags=128};'callback' {$script:state.File.Aces[0].Ordinary=$false};'wrong-right' {$script:state.File.Aces[0].Mask=2};'wrong-sid' {$script:state.File.Aces[0].Sid='S-1-5-18'}}
Reject {Get-WelaFileProbeStateKey $script:state} 'No existing ordinary success ReadData'
}
foreach($name in @('kind','nonce','pid','executable','path','clock','success','calls','bytes','handle','before','after','token-drift','reader-drift','pre-launch','post-observed','reverse')){
foreach($name in @('kind','nonce','pid','executable','path','clock','phase-type','phase-name','return-before','return-after','success','calls','bytes','handle','before','after','token-drift','reader-drift','pre-launch','post-observed','reverse')){
New-Fixture
switch($name){'kind' {$script:operation.Kind=$true};'nonce' {$script:operation.Nonce=$true};'pid' {$script:operation.ProcessId=$true};'executable' {$script:operation.Executable=$true};'path' {$script:operation.FilePath=$true};'clock' {$script:operation.Read.Clock=$true};'success' {$script:operation.Read.Succeeded='true'};'calls' {$script:operation.Read.ReadCalls=$true};'bytes' {$script:operation.Read.BytesRead=$true};'handle' {$script:operation.Read.HandleId='0x0'};'before' {$script:operation.Read.BeforeKey=$true};'after' {$script:operation.Read.AfterKey='e'*64};'token-drift' {$script:operation.AfterToken.Privileges[0].Attributes=2};'reader-drift' {$script:operation.AfterReader.ModifiedId='999'};'pre-launch' {$script:operation.Read.StartedUtc='2026-09-20T23:59:59Z'};'post-observed' {$script:operation.Read.CompletedUtc='2026-09-21T00:00:02Z'};'reverse' {$script:operation.Read.CompletedUtc='2026-09-21T00:00:00Z'}}
switch($name){'kind' {$script:operation.Kind=$true};'nonce' {$script:operation.Nonce=$true};'pid' {$script:operation.ProcessId=$true};'executable' {$script:operation.Executable=$true};'path' {$script:operation.FilePath=$true};'clock' {$script:operation.Read.Clock=$true};'phase-type' {$script:operation.Read.Phase=$true};'phase-name' {$script:operation.Read.Phase='Other'};'return-before' {$script:operation.Read.ReadReturnedUtc='2026-09-21T00:00:00.0000999Z'};'return-after' {$script:operation.Read.ReadReturnedUtc='2026-09-21T00:00:00.0002001Z'};'success' {$script:operation.Read.Succeeded='true'};'calls' {$script:operation.Read.ReadCalls=$true};'bytes' {$script:operation.Read.BytesRead=$true};'handle' {$script:operation.Read.HandleId='0x0'};'before' {$script:operation.Read.BeforeKey=$true};'after' {$script:operation.Read.AfterKey='e'*64};'token-drift' {$script:operation.AfterToken.Privileges[0].Attributes=2};'reader-drift' {$script:operation.AfterReader.ModifiedId='999'};'pre-launch' {$script:operation.Read.StartedUtc='2026-09-20T23:59:59Z'};'post-observed' {$script:operation.Read.CompletedUtc='2026-09-21T00:00:02Z'};'reverse' {$script:operation.Read.CompletedUtc='2026-09-21T00:00:00Z'}}
Reject {Assert-WelaFileProbeOperation $script:operation $script:state $script:nonce 1234 ([datetimeoffset]'2026-09-21T00:00:00Z') ([datetimeoffset]'2026-09-21T00:00:01Z')} 'authority|identity|receipt|Expected|token|interval'
}
New-Fixture;$xml=Native-Xml
@@ -50,7 +54,8 @@ foreach($change in @(@('4663','4662'),@('<Version>1','<Version>0'),@('0x80200000
Assert (Test-WelaFileProbeEvent $xml.Replace('ReadCase.TxT','readcase.txt').Replace('System32','SYSTEM32').Replace('%%4416',' %%4416 ') $script:operation $script:state) 'Windows path casing and native access-list whitespace do not change identity/right'
Assert (Test-WelaFileProbeEvent $xml.Replace($script:state.File.Path,$script:state.File.NativePath.ToLowerInvariant()) $script:operation $script:state) 'the exact same-handle observed NT path is accepted case-insensitively'
foreach($wrong in @('\Device\HarddiskVolume6\Fixture\ReadCase.TxT','\Device\HarddiskVolume5\Elsewhere\ReadCase.TxT','\Device\HarddiskVolume5\Fixture\Other.TxT')){Assert (-not(Test-WelaFileProbeEvent $xml.Replace($script:state.File.Path,$wrong) $script:operation $script:state)) 'other NT volumes and paths remain rejected'}
foreach($time in @('0001000Z','0002000Z')){Assert (Test-WelaFileProbeEvent $xml.Replace('0001500Z',$time) $script:operation $script:state) 'exact precise interval boundaries are inclusive'}
Assert (Test-WelaFileProbeEvent $xml.Replace('0001500Z','0001800Z') $script:operation $script:state) 'an event after ReadFile returns but inside actual held-identity readback phase remains attributable'
foreach($time in @('0001000Z','0002000Z')){Assert (Test-WelaFileProbeEvent $xml.Replace('0001500Z',$time) $script:operation $script:state) 'exact measured phase boundaries are inclusive'}
Assert (-not(Test-WelaFileProbeEvent $xml.Replace('</EventData>','<Data Name="AccessMask">0x1</Data></EventData>') $script:operation $script:state)) 'duplicate XML authority is refused'
Assert (-not(Test-WelaFileProbeEvent ('<!DOCTYPE Event [<!ENTITY x "x">]>'+$xml) $script:operation $script:state)) 'DTD evidence is refused'
Assert (-not(Test-WelaFileProbeEvent ('<wrapper>'+$xml+'</wrapper>') $script:operation $script:state)) 'wrapped event is refused'
+13 -4
View File
@@ -11,7 +11,9 @@ function Policy-Key($Policy){$ordered=[ordered]@{};foreach($key in @($Policy.Key
function Invoke-PublicFileProbe([string[]]$Arguments,[string]$Log,[bool]$Success=$true){$old=$ErrorActionPreference;try{$ErrorActionPreference='Continue';$lines=@(& $engine -NoLogo -NoProfile -NonInteractive -File (Join-Path $script:ScriptRoot 'WELA.ps1') @Arguments 2>&1);$code=$LASTEXITCODE}finally{$ErrorActionPreference=$old;$global:LASTEXITCODE=0};$text=$lines -join "`n";[IO.File]::WriteAllText($Log,$text,[Text.UTF8Encoding]::new($false));if(($Success -and $code -ne 0) -or (-not $Success -and $code -eq 0)){throw "Unexpected public CLI result $code : $text"};$start=$text.IndexOf('{');if($start -lt 0){throw 'Public CLI returned no JSON report.'};ConvertFrom-WelaArrivalJson $text.Substring($start)}
function Add-OwnedReadSacl([string]$Path){$privilege=[Wela.SelectedSacl.Privilege]::new();$target=$null;try{$target=[Wela.SelectedSacl.Target]::new('FileSystem',$Path);$before=$target.Read();$null=$target.Add($before.Identity,$before.DescriptorBase64,'S-1-1-0',1,64)}finally{if($target){$target.Dispose()};$privilege.Dispose()}}
$root=New-WelaArrivalOutput (Join-Path $env:RUNNER_TEMP ('wela-file-access-'+[guid]::NewGuid().ToString('N'))) $script:ScriptRoot
$targetRoot=Join-Path $root 'owned-targets';$null=New-Item -ItemType Directory $targetRoot
# The hosted runner's data volume can classify4663 as Removable Storage (Task12812).
# Own an ordinary private system-volume directory for the strict File System Task12800 fixture.
$targetRoot=New-WelaArrivalOutput (Join-Path (Join-Path $env:SystemRoot 'Temp') ('wela-file-access-targets-'+[guid]::NewGuid().ToString('N'))) $script:ScriptRoot
$file=Join-Path $targetRoot 'ReadCase.TxT';$plain=Join-Path $targetRoot 'WithoutAudit.txt'
[IO.File]::WriteAllText($file,'WELA owned harmless file probe fixture.',[Text.UTF8Encoding]::new($false));[IO.File]::WriteAllText($plain,'WELA owned file without a matching audit ACE.',[Text.UTF8Encoding]::new($false))
$fileHash=(Get-FileHash $file).Hash;$beforePolicies=Get-WelaEffectiveAuditPolicy;$precedencePath='HKLM:\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Control\Lsa';$beforePrecedence=Get-WelaRegistryState $precedencePath SCENoApplyLegacyAuditPolicy
@@ -29,9 +31,10 @@ try {
$output=Join-Path $root ('run-'+$index)
$report=Invoke-PublicFileProbe @('file-access-probe','-FileProbeAction','Run','-FileProbePath',$file.ToLowerInvariant(),'-FileProbeOutputPath',$output) (Join-Path $root ('run-'+$index+'.log'))
Assert ($report.Status -ceq 'FileReadObserved' -and $report.Matches -eq 1) 'public one-byte read produced exactly one attributable actual4663'
Assert ($report.Operation.Read.Phase -ceq 'OneByteReadAndHeldIdentityReadback' -and (ConvertTo-WelaArrivalUtc $report.Operation.Read.StartedUtc) -le (ConvertTo-WelaArrivalUtc $report.Operation.Read.ReadReturnedUtc) -and (ConvertTo-WelaArrivalUtc $report.Operation.Read.ReadReturnedUtc) -le (ConvertTo-WelaArrivalUtc $report.Operation.Read.CompletedUtc)) 'actual phase retains separate ordered precise read-start, ReadFile-return and held-identity-readback completion timestamps'
Assert ($report.Operation.Read.ReadCalls -eq 1 -and $report.Operation.Read.BytesRead -eq 1 -and $report.RetainedContentBytes -eq 0 -and $report.SigmaEvtxCredit -eq 0) 'one byte is read without retaining contents or granting Sigma credit'
Assert ($report.Before.File.StateKey -ceq $beforeKey -and $report.After.File.StateKey -ceq $beforeKey -and (Get-FileHash $file).Hash -ceq $fileHash) 'existing file data, native identity and full descriptor remain unchanged'
Assert (Test-WelaFileProbeEvent ([IO.File]::ReadAllText((Join-Path $output 'event.xml'))) $report.Operation $report.Before) 'retained native XML matches operation PID, handle, SID, logon, path, right and precise interval'
Assert (Test-WelaFileProbeEvent ([IO.File]::ReadAllText((Join-Path $output 'event.xml'))) $report.Operation $report.Before) 'retained native XML matches operation PID, handle, SID, logon, path, right and measured read/readback phase'
foreach($artifact in $report.Artifacts){Assert ((Get-FileHash (Join-Path $output $artifact.Name)).Hash.ToLowerInvariant() -ceq $artifact.Sha256) 'retained artifact hash matches its public manifest'}
}
$missing=Invoke-PublicFileProbe @('file-access-probe','-FileProbePath',$plain) (Join-Path $root 'missing-sacl.log') $false
@@ -41,13 +44,19 @@ try {
Assert ($disabled.Status -ceq 'Unverified' -and $disabled.Diagnostic -match 'File System success auditing' -and $null -eq $disabled.Operation) 'real disabled auditing refuses the byte read'
Assert (-not(Test-Path (Join-Path $root 'disabled-policy/intent.json'))) 'failed prerequisites produce no pending read intent'
Set-WelaEffectiveAuditPolicy -Guid '0CCE921D-69AE-11D9-BED3-505054503030' -Mask 1 -Mode exact
foreach($target in @((Join-Path $script:ScriptRoot 'WELA.ps1'),$engine)){
$refused=Invoke-PublicFileProbe @('file-access-probe','-FileProbePath',$target) (Join-Path $root ('scope-refusal-'+[guid]::NewGuid().ToString('N')+'.log')) $false
Assert ($refused.Status -ceq 'Unverified' -and $null -eq $refused.Before -and $refused.Diagnostic -match 'source tree|active PowerShell engine') 'actual implementation/engine targets are refused before prerequisite hashes'
}
$oldState=Get-WelaFileProbeState $file
$replacement=Join-Path $targetRoot 'Replacement.txt';[IO.File]::WriteAllText($replacement,'WELA owned replacement.',[Text.UTF8Encoding]::new($false));Add-OwnedReadSacl $replacement
Remove-Item -LiteralPath $file -Force;Move-Item -LiteralPath $replacement -Destination $file
$message='';try{Start-WelaFileProbeRead $oldState (Join-Path $root 'not-used.json') ([guid]::NewGuid().ToString('N'))|Out-Null}catch{$message=$_.Exception.Message}
Assert ($message -match 'drifted before worker launch') 'real replaced native file identity refuses a stale preflight before launching a worker'
$held=[Wela.FileAccessProbe.FileHandle]::new($file,$false)
try{$denied=$false;try{Remove-Item -LiteralPath $file -Force -ErrorAction Stop}catch{$denied=$true};Assert $denied 'held native observation handle prevents deletion of the selected file'}finally{$held.Dispose()}
# Metadata-only desired access does not enforce data/delete sharing restrictions.
# Acquire READ_DATA for this fixture lock check without issuing a ReadFile call.
$held=[Wela.FileAccessProbe.FileHandle]::new($file,$true)
try{$denied=$false;try{Remove-Item -LiteralPath $file -Force -ErrorAction Stop}catch{$denied=$true};Assert $denied 'held native data-capable handle prevents deletion of the selected file'}finally{$held.Dispose()}
} finally {
if($changed){try{Set-WelaEffectiveAuditPolicy -Guid '0CCE921D-69AE-11D9-BED3-505054503030' -Mask $beforePolicies['0CCE921D-69AE-11D9-BED3-505054503030'] -Mode exact;if($beforePrecedence.ValueExists){Set-ItemProperty -LiteralPath $precedencePath -Name SCENoApplyLegacyAuditPolicy -Type $beforePrecedence.Type -Value $beforePrecedence.Value}else{Remove-ItemProperty -LiteralPath $precedencePath -Name SCENoApplyLegacyAuditPolicy -ErrorAction Stop}}catch{$cleanupErrors+=$_.Exception.Message}}
$auditRestored=(Policy-Key (Get-WelaEffectiveAuditPolicy)) -ceq (Policy-Key $beforePolicies)